In Reply to: A perfect movie posted by rico on December 5, 2003 at 10:31:59:
I shallow and formulaic, cliche-driven, with some good acting but nothing too aspiring.One can't answer your call for a "perfect" movie without identifying what he is looking for. But I would say virtually any early Fellini is head and shoulders above the Casablanca, and something like Bicycle Thief dwarfs it handily.
BTW - none of them is really "perfect", but exceptionally good - yes.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- A perfect movie? It is OK, I think - Victor Khomenko 10:40:04 12/05/03 (8)
- The Bicycle Thief? Your derailleur gear needs fine tuning! I've seen that flick; it's okay, but it ain't NO Casablanca! - Audiophilander 11:14:22 12/05/03 (7)
- It's nuts to compare these two films....might as well try and say - tinear 18:17:03 12/05/03 (0)
- Re: How can you dare to compare " an accident* " film - patrickU 11:49:32 12/05/03 (5)
- Rick Blane vs. Fantomas - Victor Khomenko 12:16:49 12/05/03 (4)
- Re: Rick Blane vs. Fantomas - patrickU 12:44:01 12/05/03 (3)
- I agree. I too like Casablanca, as one of the better films of the cool superman genre - Victor Khomenko 12:53:02 12/05/03 (2)
- Re: I agree. I too like Casablanca, as one of the better films of the cool superman genre - patrickU 13:43:50 12/05/03 (1)
- Re: My all time favorite Bronson critiical comment - rico 17:44:15 12/05/03 (0)