Different strokes.... I had never seen the original until recently...

Posted by TWB (A) on April 6, 2019 at 19:31:14

In Reply to: This was the moment when my hopes died posted by Victor Khomenko on April 6, 2019 at 19:04:07:

while I found it to be a sweet story, in comparison to the Garland/Mason or Streisand/Kristofferson versions I thought it was weak. Both of the later versions did a better job of establishing a believable loving relationship between the stars. In the original not so much....

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - A Star is Born... the remake - Victor Khomenko 18:57:19 04/01/19 (14)

"uninvolving music"..... how ANYONE could refer to THIS.... - TWB 18:34:27 04/06/19 (9)

RE: "uninvolving music"..... how ANYONE could refer to THIS.... - volunteer 03:02:54 04/07/19 (6)

RE: "uninvolving music"..... how ANYONE could refer to THIS.... - RGA 06:14:17 04/08/19 (5)

Garland was known to those that saw her live for her.... - TWB 18:50:17 04/08/19 (2)

RE: Garland was known to those that saw her live for her.... - RGA 02:47:32 04/11/19 (1)

I Could Go On Singing... is probably her greatest... - TWB 10:35:50 04/14/19 (0)

Every era is different - Victor Khomenko 13:05:05 04/08/19 (1)

RE: Every era is different - RGA 03:12:04 04/11/19 (0)

This was the moment when my hopes died - Victor Khomenko 19:04:07 04/06/19 (1)

Different strokes.... I had never seen the original until recently... - TWB 19:31:14 04/06/19 (0)

Complete agreement. Mason was the best thing in the film. - volunteer 15:57:50 04/02/19 (2)

RE: Complete agreement. Mason was the best thing in the film. - Des 19:25:26 04/02/19 (1)

To clarify my concern regarding Mason - Victor Khomenko 09:21:28 04/03/19 (0)

RE: A Star is Born... the remake - beach cruiser 15:37:19 04/02/19 (0)

Follow Ups

Different strokes.... I had never seen the original until recently... - TWB 19:31:14 04/06/19 (0)

Different strokes.... I had never seen the original until recently...

Post a Message!