RE: Garland was known to those that saw her live for her....

Posted by RGA (R) on April 11, 2019 at 02:47:32

In Reply to: Garland was known to those that saw her live for her.... posted by TWB on April 8, 2019 at 18:50:17:

Garland = great - no issue with her or her singing and not really with her acting since it is just the way acting was at the time.

The clip you just showed illustrates to me why I prefer less backing instruments with good singers. She could literally have sung that song A Capella and IMO it would Literally have been much better.

That is another issue for me with music from the era - the loud brash brass bands shouting over everything - FFS - I wish we could just get her vocal track and get the rest of the cacophony out of there. at 1:52. I can live with it, I just wish it wasn't there.

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - A Star is Born... the remake - Victor Khomenko 18:57:19 04/01/19 (14)

"uninvolving music"..... how ANYONE could refer to THIS.... - TWB 18:34:27 04/06/19 (9)

RE: "uninvolving music"..... how ANYONE could refer to THIS.... - volunteer 03:02:54 04/07/19 (6)

RE: "uninvolving music"..... how ANYONE could refer to THIS.... - RGA 06:14:17 04/08/19 (5)

Garland was known to those that saw her live for her.... - TWB 18:50:17 04/08/19 (2)

RE: Garland was known to those that saw her live for her.... - RGA 02:47:32 04/11/19 (1)

I Could Go On Singing... is probably her greatest... - TWB 10:35:50 04/14/19 (0)

Every era is different - Victor Khomenko 13:05:05 04/08/19 (1)

RE: Every era is different - RGA 03:12:04 04/11/19 (0)

This was the moment when my hopes died - Victor Khomenko 19:04:07 04/06/19 (1)

Different strokes.... I had never seen the original until recently... - TWB 19:31:14 04/06/19 (0)

Complete agreement. Mason was the best thing in the film. - volunteer 15:57:50 04/02/19 (2)

RE: Complete agreement. Mason was the best thing in the film. - Des 19:25:26 04/02/19 (1)

To clarify my concern regarding Mason - Victor Khomenko 09:21:28 04/03/19 (0)

RE: A Star is Born... the remake - beach cruiser 15:37:19 04/02/19 (0)

Follow Ups

RE: Garland was known to those that saw her live for her.... - RGA 02:47:32 04/11/19 (1)

I Could Go On Singing... is probably her greatest... - TWB 10:35:50 04/14/19 (0)

RE: Garland was known to those that saw her live for her....

Post a Message!