Home Films/DVD Asylum

Movies from comedy to drama to your favorite Hollyweird Star.

[ Follow Ups ] Thread: [ Display  All  Email ] [ Films/DVD Asylum ]
[ Alert Moderator ]

Re: Did I detect an hint of....

"You took time and patience, that is good."

Thank you.


Victor wife did took the pencil and wrote a little more on it, if I remember...Victor just comment.

My dismisal was of Victor's dismisal of a movie he never bothered to watch.

"Change my prejudice..After seeing the first two parts, should I have put to electronic paper. So it was not the prejudice you meant."

Fair enough.


"You see if it would have been a deeply interesting movie I would certainly have more to say on it, but the "utterly wrong " are words directed at people like me who does not have to takes a lot to describe this kind of movies, it is more of a bridge..a short cut if you want, but I also told what was wrong!"

Sorry but one cannot rationalize a dismismal without support based on the opinion that the dismisal was warrented. It looks like you are saying you can call a movie crap without explination because you are simply right. I'm not buying that.


"Again, it was loud and over digital bright,"

You cannot make a universal claim based on a single viewing in one theater. Most movies are too loud and too bright because they are played back to loudly on systems that are too bright. Not the fault of the film makers.

"the actors seems lost behind a blue screen,"

Not every matt shot was perfect but I'd lay odds you missed the majority of them because they were done so well. It isn't easy to create another world with a rich history without the occassional technical error or the occassional performace problem.


" the story was a little bit confused."

The story was very dense with an entirely invented world full of diverse cultures, each with it's own rich history. But if you knew the material you would know that it was amazingly clear given all the content of the books. It is impossible for that much material to be clear on the first viewing.


"I never read or only if I really can not make my mind, what is more than seldom critic reviews, after writing the few thoughts I had on it I actually did ...and a lot of them like me did find this four endings boring and execessive, but if I were the only one it would not disturb me."

I am glad that you are independent. However, the ending was IMO neither excessive nor boring. I found the subtle examination of life after the greatest adventure to be quite moving. The pictures of Sam living his life on the Shire after all that he had been through and after loosing his best friend, the person he shared this amazing adventure with to be quite poignient and layered in it's emotional content.


"So again what can one discuss of depth, when there is none?"

You aasume to be the arbritator of depth now. the depth is there. Just because you are not in tune with it doesn't make it nonexistant.


" Beside that I did wrote a lot more on this film, that it is worth.
Tons and tons."


I didn't find anymore than what I cited other than more out of hand dismisals. But you are always free to cite what I may have missed.


"The problem is that is amps are not kaka."

Niether is LOTRs. The real problem is calling something kaka without even experiencing it.


"The way you describe the film is the way this film SHOULD have been."

No I am describing what I saw.


"Helas it is not."

LOTRs is arguably the greatest myth of the twentienth century. It is arguably amoung the greatest myths in the history of liturayure. It is inarguably the most developed and carefully thought out myth ever.


"It is noisy, incoherent and badly played."

Nope.

in juxtaposition the " Star Wars " are just a pleasure.

The first two are great movies IMO.


"And again I wrote why in more than one post."

I haven't found it.


"See you on a brand new film, with renewed energy!"


This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
  Signature Sound   [ Signature Sound Lounge ]

Follow Ups Full Thread
Follow Ups
You can not post to an archived thread.

[ Top Top of Page ] [ Contact Us ] [ Support/Wish List ] [ Copyright © 2024, Audio Asylum, all rights reserved ]
[ General ] [ Speakers ] [ Tubes ] [ Vinyl ] [ Digital ] [ Hi-Rez ] [ Video Asylum ] [ Cables ] [ Tweaks/DIY ] [ Music ] [ Films ]