Quite a few would grant her the ascendant position on the pedestal of modern actresses.
I remain very impressed with her earlier work. Has a bigger bitch ever been portrayed so cunningly as in "Kramer vs Kramer?"
How about the faithful, kind girlfriend of "The Deer Hunter?"
In "French Lieutenant's Woman," however, I believe she did her best work: a bravura performance.
"Silkwood" began her descent: neither she, nor any other actor, can play all roles. She seemed like a Yalie trying to mimic a working class woman. (Bette Davis, otoh, did a masterful job of it in "Of Human Bondage.")
From then on, it was a series of "accent" roles.
So, in answer to my own question, I'd say early Meryl deserves the accolade "great," but for the past several decades, she has been a sort of mimic, both of dialects and emotions.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Is Meryl Streep the most overrated American actress? - tinear 09:26:57 04/04/04 (10)
- M. Streep ain't bad, but she's no Julia Roberts!!! (nt) - Sean Jean 06:46:04 04/05/04 (0)
- No way. Streep has range. Most overrated goes to... - glennw 21:15:08 04/04/04 (0)
- Silkwood - Gee LP 15:35:42 04/04/04 (0)
- Uh, no... - JefferyK 15:28:58 04/04/04 (0)
- She's no Binoche... - RGA 15:08:52 04/04/04 (3)
- Wrong! - EBerlin 21:18:24 04/04/04 (2)
- Hahaha - RGA 23:32:29 04/04/04 (1)
- Re: Hahaha - EBerlin 05:35:59 04/05/04 (0)
- Re: Is Meryl Streep the most overrated American actress? - rico 14:35:14 04/04/04 (0)
- Re: Is Meryl Streep the most overrated American actress? - patrickU 11:34:30 04/04/04 (0)