In Reply to: Well its sure no... posted by Joe S on April 27, 2000 at 14:30:58:
Well, I grant you the 3 1950s era US movies I mentioned don't convey the grubbiness and smelliness of "pigboat" life like "DB." They are, as far as I can tell otherwise pretty accurate. Run Silent was written by Edward Beach, a submariner during WW2 who later commanded the first US nuclear powered sub, the "Nautilus." I don't know if the screenplay writers of Enemy and Hellcats had similar credentials, but I do know that a book by Adm. Richard (?) Fluckey, the US WW2 sub captain with the highest sunk tonnage (who wasn't KIA) and who was awarded the Cong. Medal of Honor, describes conducting a landing party raid similar to that shown in Hellcats.Sounds like maybe I'll wait for U-571 to hit video or pay-per-view.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Well its sure no... hmmmmm . . . - Bruce from DC 15:22:24 04/27/00 (19)
- Re: Well its sure no... hmmmmm . . . - Mart 00:24:44 04/28/00 (5)
- Re: Well its sure no... hmmmmm . . . - Victor Khomenko 05:19:26 04/28/00 (3)
- that's surprising . . . - Mart 07:34:05 04/29/00 (2)
- Works great on junk channels too - Victor Khomenko 07:49:49 04/29/00 (1)
- Yes, but to the point ... - Mart 22:02:27 04/30/00 (0)
- oops, meant for VK <nt> - Mart 00:25:57 04/28/00 (0)
- Hey, if you like sub flicks... - Joe S 21:36:20 04/27/00 (0)
- Maybe not accurate but still entertaining> - Tranny 16:03:19 04/27/00 (11)
- Definitely not accurate but maybe still entertaining> - Joe S 21:31:25 04/27/00 (5)
- Re: Definitely not accurate but maybe still entertaining> - Victor Khomenko 05:15:24 04/28/00 (4)
- Re: Definitely not accurate but maybe still entertaining> - Joe S 07:02:31 04/28/00 (3)
- LOL, I see.... and how about that Stuka Pilot? - Victor Khomenko 07:17:42 04/28/00 (2)
- Or the fighter pilot... - Joe S 09:14:10 04/28/00 (0)
- Hans-Ulrich Rudel - The Stuka Pilot - Victor Khomenko 07:46:28 04/28/00 (0)
- And speaking of Keitel... - Victor Khomenko 18:37:38 04/27/00 (4)
- VK, if you like Harvey.. - Tranny 13:39:48 04/28/00 (1)
- Will definitely consider. Thank you. (nt) - Victor Khomenko 14:12:25 04/28/00 (0)
- Re: And speaking of Keitel... - Larry S 19:07:14 04/27/00 (1)
- Thank you, that sounds right. - Victor Khomenko 19:40:20 04/27/00 (0)