In Reply to: "Dogville" posted by rico on August 7, 2005 at 11:48:11:
wrong-headed review, but a step in the wrong direction is at least motion.
Actually, it's a brilliantly conceived "filmed play," with a startling performance by Nicole Kidman.
The film transcends cultures quite well: I saw it in an art theater in Belo Horizonte (the capital of Minas Gerais state, Brasil) and the crowd burst into applause when it ended.
Anyone that has enjoyed Thornton Wilder's Our Town should see this darker-sided companion piece.
Kidman should have received an Oscar for her performance.
Warning: if absolutely you hate theater, the presentation of dialogue and ideas as opposed to non-stop violence and action...don't bother. There is plenty happening here, it's just an internal struggle; that said, it is manifested by Kidman and the emotional journey she makes is riveting.
One of the greatest commentaries on American culture ever filmed; of course, it took a foreigner to do it.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Well, at least you're beginning to understand what this forum's about: - tinear 13:19:16 08/07/05 (13)
- Re: Well, at least you're beginning to understand what this forum's about: - jamesgarvin 15:50:28 08/07/05 (5)
- Just two words, Jimmy. - tinear 17:10:13 08/07/05 (4)
- How's that - jamesgarvin 18:06:11 08/07/05 (3)
- Two more: - tinear 07:19:37 08/08/05 (2)
- Re: Two more: - jamesgarvin 14:13:43 08/08/05 (0)
- Re: Two more: - jamesgarvin 10:17:31 08/08/05 (0)
- I thought it was an amazing film (or filmed play) that delved deeply into - sjb 13:23:29 08/07/05 (6)
- You, sir, obviously are a gentleman and a scholar. If I'm not - tinear 15:08:21 08/07/05 (5)
- I greatly enjoyed both Dogville and Beaking the Waves (nt) - Doug Flynn 00:48:10 08/08/05 (0)
- Yeah... but I think The Ice Storm is a very good film - sjb 16:21:18 08/07/05 (2)
- Ok, forget half of what I said. nt - tinear 17:12:16 08/07/05 (1)
- So what does that make me - sjb 21:10:43 08/07/05 (0)
- You are correct - jamesgarvin 15:52:16 08/07/05 (0)