In Reply to: Slumdog Millionaire posted by padreken on April 12, 2009 at 22:24:41:
Yeah, talk about manipulative. Did you notice the angry Hindu mob screaming "they're muslim, let's get 'em!" and promptly murdering the boys' mother? Imagine all the westerners who left the theater thinking how wronged those poor innocent Muslims are. Nevermind that they just turned Mumbai into a terrorist attack zone or that India is dotted with mosques built right on top of the ruins of gorgeous Hindu temples.
I also was horrified at how, after raping his brother's girlfriend at gunpoint and basically conducting himself as a gangster/aspiring terrorist, Salim thoroughly redeemed himself by going out in a blaze of suicidal glory screaming "God is great". The whole film was like a propaganda piece from CAIR.
I won't even get into the whole western gameshow part of the plot. Really in poor taste and exploitative. The real problem in India is the caste system, which was not even explored.
-------------
We must be the change we wish to see in the world. -Gandhi
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Hated it - Jazz Inmate 09:13:29 04/13/09 (25)
- Its a movie, Jazz. A make believe drama. As an Indian I am not offended. Why are you? - Arya 13:16:55 04/22/09 (0)
- But wait, the consensus of (206) reviewers on Rotten Tomatoes is that it was great - sjb 12:20:47 04/14/09 (2)
- Popularity means a lot to you poll-watchers, but it means nothing to me NT - Jazz Inmate 08:38:00 04/15/09 (1)
- Well, at least you weren't cursed with self-awareness. - sjb 08:53:01 04/15/09 (0)
- Dumbdog Millionaire = way too much violence by adults against children - Richard BassNut Greene 08:46:57 04/14/09 (1)
- RE: "...refused to deliver my message..." - powermatic 11:13:43 04/18/09 (0)
- If one leaves his baggage at the door and takes this film for what it is then it's watchable. - Tony D. 18:10:39 04/13/09 (4)
- The movie was nothing more than white-guilt bollocks. * - mr grits 08:35:50 04/14/09 (0)
- I watched it. Therefore it's watchable. But it sucked - Jazz Inmate 23:35:09 04/13/09 (2)
- Well, as I said it takes the ability to get past ones bias and it helps if one is knowledgable about the - Tony D. 07:24:34 04/14/09 (1)
- well then it sounds like you're the one who needs to drop your suitcase at the door NT - Jazz Inmate 10:10:26 04/14/09 (0)
- Damn stupid INdians not even knowing what they should make films about - dave c 13:57:27 04/13/09 (7)
- Excuse me but the film was made by the same brit who made trainspotting - Jazz Inmate 23:23:08 04/13/09 (6)
- Several people would disagree - dave c 22:27:02 04/14/09 (5)
- You disagree that the director is Danny Boyle? NT - Jazz Inmate 08:44:10 04/15/09 (4)
- so you didn't bother with the link? - dave c 13:50:03 04/15/09 (3)
- Yeah, there were a lot of Indian folks in the cast and crew because the movie was...you know...FILMED IN INDIA - Jazz Inmate 19:50:41 04/15/09 (2)
- "why boyle was involved in the first place": Because he thought he could make a good film and some money? - dave c 14:09:12 04/16/09 (1)
- ...by grossly manipulating reality, absolving Islam of any blame in violence and exploiting children - Jazz Inmate 10:17:55 04/21/09 (0)
- News flash: the caste system isn't Muslim. Try really hard to figure out......... nt - tinear 12:38:37 04/13/09 (5)
- Newsflash. There IS caste system in muslims too * - Arya 13:18:10 04/22/09 (0)
- Newsflash: I never said it was. If you want to have a conversation, pick something i said and talk about it NT - Jazz Inmate 23:36:44 04/13/09 (3)
- Your sarcastic ".... poor little Muslims" comment opened the door, - tinear 07:48:56 04/14/09 (2)
- Anyone who's against violence, intolerance, misogyny and sharia law should have issues with Islam - Jazz Inmate 12:22:43 04/15/09 (1)
- Errrr.... so no more films about Nazi Germany.... they were nasty to a lot of people - dave c 18:23:26 04/15/09 (0)