|
Audio Asylum Thread Printer Get a view of an entire thread on one page |
For Sale Ads |
In Reply to: my take on malena posted by njjohn on September 25, 2002 at 20:18:01:
the thought finally came to me, what i was trying to understand during the film but it was not coming to me. perhaps the main point of the film.it's this. the boy's way was incredibly aberrant in a way, yet through his persistence, he was the one in the right place and right time to do the most good. to rectify the situation and do the most healing of the community.
the father too. the father's ways were a bit unbearable yet he eventually, through his unique ways, played the key role for his son.
that's a little bit like the idea in 'from dusk till dawn'. in dusk till dawn, the worst features of the characters in the initial part of the movie, were what you wanted them to have when it came time to fight the zombies. but in that film, that was purposeful manipulation of one variable.
this is a slighty similar phenonema in malena, but it is weaved into the film naturally, so that you wouldn't even know it unless you thought about it.
Follow Ups:
Interesting how much you found in one good film... not really surprising, given the "thoughful" nature of the movie. I think you touched on it - the film doesn't break any new grounds, you constantly feel you have already seen this, and this is perhaps its major fault. For instance, the truly great films can be talking about extremely simle subject but keep you riveted - after all, what's happening there in Bergman's Persona?Overal I would rate Malena as a more interesting and deep film than Amelie, but of course the subject is boring to most American audience, and it is too serious to become a 'darling'. So it went largely unnoticed - shame, given its relatively high (even by the European standards) level.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors: