In Reply to: John, you have a right to an educated opinion ... posted by Audiophilander on November 29, 2001 at 21:26:22:
"If that were true, and it isn't, the same could be said about all genres of imaginative fiction be it western, romance, horror, mystery and much of what passes for mainstream."Aye, there's the Wub. Is IS said of all genres.
SF holds no special place in the world of literature or cinema or TV. The criteria which determine a successful work are not necessarily the same criteria which determine a work's value, importance or comparitive merit. ("The fact that you only find SF worthy of laughter "- Only SF ? Are you psychic ? Did you ken this with your super- powers ?)
Surely there's some room for discernment ?
My plebeian comments ? The plebeians vote at the box office with their cash. Bread and circuses, popcorn and cinema.
(Would that all SF fans know who a plebeian was. Would that all SF fans bother to read something more challenging than an extended comic sans graphics -nuff said.)
You may take umbrage, and a petty insult about a "limited imagination" is weak- save your pity for those that are impressed with the imagination displayed in Star Trek.
Just put on your tights and go save us from the evil SeriousLiterature Man !!!!!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Super Auph to the rescue ! - john dem 22:07:17 11/29/01 (15)
- Up, up and away! - Audiophilander 06:58:32 11/30/01 (14)
- Defying logic is not a super power, Super Auph. - john dem 11:24:18 11/30/01 (12)
- The poster's logic lacks Vulcanization! ;^) - Audiophilander 01:31:05 12/01/01 (11)
- You're the one burning rubber to get away from your absurd assertions. - john dem 13:56:17 12/01/01 (10)
- To the contrary, my prophylactic response is quite logical: - Audiophilander 15:07:22 12/03/01 (0)
- the remains of the day - late 18:49:17 12/01/01 (8)
- Re: the remains of the day - Bruce from DC 06:40:19 12/03/01 (1)
- good post, minor quibble(s) - late 07:27:57 12/07/01 (0)
- Enter late, defender of the punyverse. - john dem 19:42:47 12/01/01 (5)
- intuitively obvious to the casual observer - late 21:51:33 12/01/01 (4)
- Yes, it is obvious. - john dem 23:09:50 12/01/01 (3)
- naught, plus naught, equals... - late 07:35:17 12/02/01 (2)
- Yawn...it must be late. - john dem 13:58:05 12/02/01 (1)
- Don't like losing, do you? --nt-- - late 16:16:35 12/02/01 (0)
- a tinker's damn - late 08:09:55 11/30/01 (0)