In Reply to: All you have to see posted by RGA on March 17, 2004 at 22:23:18:
Of course all this post of yours is just a bitter hollow smoke - seems like only those who believe that Hollywood is the Holy Grail of movie making do divide the world into two parts - as you are doing it here.I would love to remind you that there are probably at least fifty more countries where movies, both good and bad, are being made. So Hollywood is really just one of twenty or more places that deserve consideration.
Unlike you, I am not stuck on any such division - I watch all sorts of movies, and then I say what I feel - without paying any attention to my special attachments. So I just as routinely call a French or a Rusasian film a kaka as I do an American one. You, OTOH, have that heavy bias, one I used to see in the Soviet leaders, paranoid about any criticism of their land. And I thought I left that mindset behind twenty five years ago. I guess people are people everywhere.
What I do is the only honest approach - call them ALL as they are. I don't have particular attachment to any one country or continent. Modern Russian movies mostly suck these days - I have no problem with stating this. You apparently do.
"Now" see Hollywood films? I shall let you in on one secret - I have been watching American films since I was about five... or four... we bought our TV in 1954. Great many I saw while still in Russia - surprisingly, they also are not stuck on their own as the world best - take your hint from them. American and European films have always been shown there, old classics to smaller audience, of course.
My wife and I brought our love for good American films with us here, and we never lost it. But we also never lost the quest for quality in films. So while we dearly love many American films (true, fewer and fewer from the later years - not our fault), we are also naturally more exposed to the tremendous volume of trash that Hollywood produces every year.
Living in Russia we were largely sheltered from that trash. Now we have to swim in it.
So all your ranting shows one thing - that you have no idea of what you are talking about, but posturing and beating your chest.
I said before that I often watch ten or twelve movies a week - most of them American, natch.
Finding good films from elsewhere is hard here - thank to the narrow-minded approach many Americans take. Unfortunately, if you talk to many young people here they don't know the rest of the world even exists. Like it or not, that tendency is far less pronounced in say, Europe.
Lot of hot air in your post. Lot is simply not true.
If I were a movie lover not able to discover the rest of the world on my own, I would be grateful to someone taking time to bring us the information about the world out there. As I stated before, you may attack me personally, and my posts all you want, but one thing is certain - if someone simply blindly followed all my recommendations, he would end up quite well versed in the wonderful world of movies, the movies from all over the world. He woudl end up seeing things he didn't even know existed... like Finish films (thank Patrick for taking a lead in that area).
He would most likely disagree with some of my choices, but there is no doubt he would be much better off than if he simply ignored all my recommendations and stuck to Hollywood production.
What should I say about your silly dismissal of the movies from the rest of the world as "dreadful art house films"? I presume you simply wrote it without thinking.
Kukushka a dreadful art house movie? Beay Travail? Closey Watched Trains? Maelstrom? Mirror? Are you trying to show us how missguided you are?
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Don't be loyal to any oen country, beloyal to movie art - Victor Khomenko 04:39:04 03/18/04 (37)
- Well - RGA 21:17:43 03/18/04 (4)
- Maybe you too should ask for a separate forum - for those under 15? - Victor Khomenko 04:59:13 03/19/04 (3)
- Re: Maybe you too should ask for a separate forum - for those under 15? - RGA 21:02:20 03/19/04 (2)
- Only someone like you would confuse maturity as being corellational with age... - RGA 21:03:37 03/19/04 (1)
- He-he... you are such a weasel... read your own post - Victor Khomenko 05:46:00 03/20/04 (0)
- You are full of backhanded insults . . . - Troy 08:40:56 03/18/04 (3)
- Re: La grande Bouffe...... - patrickU 09:07:18 03/18/04 (0)
- Re: You are full of backhanded insults . . . - Victor Khomenko 08:52:10 03/18/04 (1)
- Dreadful Arthouse Movies - Troy 09:52:24 03/18/04 (0)
- Re: Of course! - patrickU 06:45:56 03/18/04 (27)
- Don't even go there, pal. - Dmitry 06:51:43 03/18/04 (19)
- Re: As Victor point it rightly out the word... - patrickU 06:56:25 03/18/04 (18)
- Please show me examples of xenophobia here. - Dmitry 07:04:57 03/18/04 (17)
- Re: Please show me examples of xenophobia here. - patrickU 07:07:33 03/18/04 (16)
- Re: Please show me examples of xenophobia here. - RGA 21:45:18 03/18/04 (8)
- Re: A statement------------------------------------------ - patrickU 04:50:00 03/19/04 (7)
- Ok - RGA 21:22:22 03/19/04 (6)
- Re: Ok - patrickU 08:15:25 03/20/04 (5)
- Re: Ok - RGA 12:25:38 03/20/04 (4)
- Re: Ok - patrickU 12:35:42 03/20/04 (3)
- Yes all ART ALL OF IT is subjective. - RGA 11:33:17 03/21/04 (2)
- Calling the Jaws a "masterpiece" cheapens the whole scale - Victor Khomenko 12:02:29 03/21/04 (1)
- WTF? - RGA 20:03:54 03/21/04 (0)
- OK, let's go verbatim. - Dmitry 07:15:47 03/18/04 (6)
- Re: OK, let's go verbatim. - Victor Khomenko 07:19:26 03/18/04 (5)
- Re: OK, let's go verbatim. - patrickU 07:26:14 03/18/04 (3)
- What exactly constitutes my rudeness? - Dmitry 07:43:13 03/18/04 (1)
- Re: You said it all.. - patrickU 08:08:06 03/18/04 (0)
- "but Dimitry is very rude." Of course! That's his race! But we live with it... nt - clarkjohnsen 07:31:59 03/18/04 (0)
- Re: OK, let's go verbatim. - Dmitry 07:26:01 03/18/04 (0)
- We do have xenophobes here, for sure - Victor Khomenko 06:48:27 03/18/04 (6)
- They any worse than our xenophiles?... nt - clarkjohnsen 07:32:49 03/18/04 (2)
- Re: Hehe...Having a good day? nt - patrickU 07:40:09 03/18/04 (1)
- We *are* amused. nt - clarkjohnsen 07:45:27 03/18/04 (0)
- Re: We do have xenophobes here, for sure - patrickU 06:50:55 03/18/04 (2)
- One did already - Victor Khomenko 06:55:30 03/18/04 (1)
- Re: One did already - patrickU 07:05:16 03/18/04 (0)