The whole eyeball thing was over the top and so implausible as to be laughable.

Posted by Audiophilander (A) on July 23, 2004 at 10:39:54

In Reply to: Another way to watch minority report posted by Bulkington on July 23, 2004 at 09:53:40:

Unfortunately, Spielberg went for the cheap thrills & gross out effects and expected folks to leave their minds and any semblance of "logic" at the door (i.e., fast pacing can cover a multitude of sins that are painfully apparent in repeated viewings). For instance, there's no way one could do a retina scan on a decomposed eye, which is exactly what Cruise's eye would be after the passage of any time and in consideration of the manner in which it was handled. The eyeball rolling across the floor scene had an almost Keystone Kop quality to it; it was predictable & lame. The fact that the security was tight when tension was desired and lax when a resolution was needed was far too precious. The spider-bots were cool, but the whole scene and bathtub set-up didn't really work, and again way to precious in terms of a last minute resolution.

IMHO, AI-Artificial Intelligence, the film that Steven Spielberg completed prior to Minority Report is FAR and away the better SF film. I do believe that Minority Report is a "return to form" for Spielberg, but that carries baggage as well as kudos. Few Directors are as good at creating and resolving tension, developing interesting characters and producing believeable effects as Mr. Spielberg, but by the same token few are as sloppy when it comes to recurring continuity gaffs, precious coincidences and obvious audience manipulation, too. There are many of his films I dearly love, but I'm often frustrated with his sloppiness as a filmmaker, especially since it's obvious how passionate he is about his craft.

Cheers,
AuPh

This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:

Follow Ups Full Thread

Topic - Duncan Shepherd on I, Robot -- Hilarious... - clarkjohnsen 07:41:39 07/22/04 (12)

Sorry, but it wasn't that bad, Shepherd's opinions notwithstanding; how about your's? - Audiophilander 10:22:08 07/22/04 (9)

Minority Report - great, I, Robot - v. good, MIBII and WWW - horrible.(nt) - mkuller 21:55:18 07/22/04 (7)

Re: Right on! - rico 02:38:46 07/23/04 (0)

With the exception of Minority Report, we're pretty much in agreement. - Audiophilander 22:55:08 07/22/04 (5)

Another way to watch minority report - Bulkington 09:53:40 07/23/04 (4)

Hi Bulkington. Please tell me what you think... - orejones 11:28:16 07/23/04 (1)

Huh - Bulkington 06:59:21 07/26/04 (0)

The whole eyeball thing was over the top and so implausible as to be laughable. - Audiophilander 10:39:54 07/23/04 (1)

Good crits. - Bulkington 13:22:59 07/25/04 (0)

Re: I, too, enjoyed it - rico 12:04:29 07/22/04 (0)

I was tired and slept through the final 15 minutes . . . - albee33 08:22:53 07/22/04 (1)

Wish I could say that about Harry Potter II and LOTR II. nt - clarkjohnsen 13:23:22 07/22/04 (0)

Follow Ups

The whole eyeball thing was over the top and so implausible as to be laughable. - Audiophilander 10:39:54 07/23/04 (1)

Good crits. - Bulkington 13:22:59 07/25/04 (0)

You can not post to an archived thread.