In Reply to: "There is no real chemistry between Norton and Biel..." - You must've been watching a different movie. posted by Audiophilander on September 5, 2006 at 10:34:25:
Hey, no offense taken. Films are wonderful, they can take you to fantastic places and are a hoot to debate. What it comes down to for me is: either a film communicates to you or it doesn't; either you are on the same wavelength as the director/actors or you're not.I liked much of the "Illusionist" and, in many ways, it's a film about what film is all about: creating an illusion and drawing you in. And to that extent, it succeeds.
But I still feel the "trick" ending was too much a matter of manipulation and lacked dramatic substance. I would have enjoyed a more subtle climax with perhaps not everyone living happily ever after. And Norton's a fine actor but didn't convey the charisma and intensity I thought necessary for the romantic lead.
I actually enjoyed the special effects. My favorite scenes involved Giamatti's facial expressions as he observes some of the "ghosts," especially when the creepy little boy stares him down.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Same movie, different ways of processing it - Ladok 12:46:54 09/05/06 (0)