In Reply to: Video switcher ain't gonna upgrade the signal posted by Dalancroft on July 3, 2002 at 10:44:08:
While the convential wisdom is more separated (Component> S-Vid > Composite) signal from the source is better, this is NOT always true. In the case of VHS, the native format of the tape is composite, so the quality of the S-video conversion chipset in the VCR determines the quality of the S-video output. An external up converter such as the Entech CVSI will turn a composite signal into a better S-video source than the VCR itself. In fact, I have tried Tivo, Replay TV, and various VCRs and found that the CVSI S-video converter was superior in all cases.The flip side would be the case of DVD where the source material is already component. Using a lower quality composite output and reconverting to component will certainly degrade the signal.
The question here is what quality is the up conversion in the RPTV?
I would recommend simply testing to find out what your percieve as the best solution.
Jason
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Video switcher ain't gonna upgrade the signal -NOT TRUE - JDog 10:39:40 07/12/02 (0)