This has been winning praise and the odd award around the world and being trailed as a VERY scary movie, compared to The Others by many.
I found it more a ghost story than a horror story.
Although there are a few moments where half the audience jumped and grabbed the other half...
Despite a couple of unnecessary scenes, this is largely a very enjoyable, very touching story of a return to a haunted (or haunting) past.
It has an unusual look of late 60s early 70s films.
There are a few holes in the plot but to expect more of a ghost story seems unreasonable.
It is, in my view, not in the same league as Pan's Labyrinth, but is a good solid film well worth taking in.
Try not to do what I did and sit behind someone very tall as it makes the subtitles very hard to read!
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - The Orphanage (El Orfanato)-no spoilers - dave c 20:50:27 05/28/08 (12)
- I liked it better the "Pan". * - mr grits 06:01:45 05/31/08 (0)
- Unfair to compare it to Pan, it's a very different film in technique, - tinear 10:44:35 05/30/08 (0)
- a solid effort - PhilJ 08:40:14 05/29/08 (0)
- Agreed - eppis1 22:24:17 05/28/08 (8)
- Guillermo del Toro wouldn't have produced crap...but I think I will sit this one out - Jazz Inmate 22:39:16 05/28/08 (7)
- I love good ghost stories... - Harmonia 23:35:40 05/28/08 (6)
- Nicholas Roeg... - dave c 14:21:04 05/29/08 (5)
- PS... - Harmonia 23:30:49 05/29/08 (1)
- Editing - dave c 23:59:59 05/29/08 (0)
- Lol, Nicholas Roeg is alive and working... - Harmonia 15:19:23 05/29/08 (2)
- Performance - dave c 16:13:30 05/29/08 (1)
- All more or less true. - Harmonia 18:02:21 05/29/08 (0)