In Reply to: With all due respect, you are rudely mistaken. posted by Audiophilander on December 23, 2003 at 10:08:00:
but I don't recall Tolkien's Ring trilogy EVER being slated as a Monty Python project!Yeah, they had their hands full with the King Arthur and Jesus thing. Had these movies come out before MP was in existence, I'm not so sure that they would have left it alone . . . it's exactly the kind of overbearing portentious junk that so many take so seriously that they make fun of.
The FX and general look will be as dated in 30 years as the 10 Commandments are today. Except that instead of a story that millions take to be true that can carry it to new generations, the hobbit stories are just silly and predictable childrens fiction.
And yes, one mans meat is another mans pudding, obviously. BBs are designed for people to put forth their opinons, whether you agree or not. My opinion that it's nothing more than a comic-book story is just that, my opinion. Some agree, some don't. Don't take it so personally.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: With all due respect, you are rudely mistaken. - Troy 10:50:44 12/23/03 (14)
- You offered no real valid literary criticisms, just a very average personal opinion, how could anybody take offense? - dennzio 13:24:40 12/23/03 (0)
- "BBs are designed for people to put forth their opinions" - Well, one hopes that those opinions would be informed! - Audiophilander 11:46:31 12/23/03 (12)
- BwaaHAAAAAAAA! - Troy 13:06:02 12/23/03 (11)
- Re: BwaaHAAAAAAAA! - Tadlo 16:23:00 12/23/03 (0)
- And just to show . . . - Troy 13:37:07 12/23/03 (9)
- Yep, missed that one. - Audiophilander 14:47:32 12/23/03 (8)
- You missed this too - Troy 15:27:24 12/23/03 (7)
- I'll accept your intent, but let's get the impression straight. - Audiophilander 22:19:30 12/24/03 (6)
- Look past your "red haze" - Troy 11:42:27 12/25/03 (5)
- "If I was a troll, I'd have handled my responses differently than I have, goading you even further." LOL! - Audiophilander 23:54:12 12/25/03 (4)
- Hey, I'm just playing nice here - Troy 17:29:54 12/26/03 (3)
- One last time; I'll see your nice ante and raise it as politely as I can: - Audiophilander 00:48:27 12/27/03 (2)
- We just don't see eye to eye - Troy 08:42:43 12/27/03 (1)
- "chasing windmills" ...? Wrong movie; wrong book! Terry Gilliam has thus far failed where Peter Jackson succeeded. - Audiophilander 09:21:51 12/29/03 (0)