Q. It seems that in past year most of your reviews end up awarding three stars or more. I had confidence in your three-star ratings until I realized that so many of them are mediocre films. For example, "Star Wars: Episode III -- Revenge of the Sith," which is composed of bad acting and unimpressive dialogue. Please be more critical of average films.Bud Schauerte, Austin, Texas
A. I often hear I am "getting soft." A correspondent helpfully writes: "My friend says that since you had cancer, you give every movie three or four stars." A New York weekly critic says I "like everything," and he must be right, because I even liked the film he cited as an example of how much more discerning he is than critics like me.
I did some math, and found that my average rating for a feature film in 2005 came to about 2.7 stars. On a bell curve, the average should be 2.0, but consider that I reviewed 284 movies in the last year, and the extra titles were independent and foreign films that tended to skew higher. I am content with my 2.7 average.
The problem is with the use of stars as a rating system. Star ratings go back to that simpler time when film critics stood on far hillsides and signaled to the grateful peasantry with torches and brightly colored flags.
Indignant readers write me: "How could you give Film A three stars and Film B only 2-1/2 stars? I will never read your reviews again." I reply: "A wise decision! My reviews are for those who are stronger in literature than math."
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Topic - Roger Ebert defends himslef against being accused as soft on movies... - RGA 19:35:14 01/04/06 (52)
- Can Any Reliable Conclusions Be Drawn About A.... - AudioHead 05:59:48 01/07/06 (9)
- Re: Can Any Reliable Conclusions Be Drawn About A.... - rico 10:33:50 01/07/06 (8)
- Re: Can Any Reliable Conclusions Be Drawn About A.... - RGA 12:55:49 01/07/06 (7)
- .Well, Do You Think That... - AudioHead 05:45:33 01/08/06 (6)
- Re: .Well, Do You Think That... - RGA 11:22:40 01/08/06 (5)
- Evidently You Think That....... - AudioHead 11:40:27 01/10/06 (4)
- Re: Evidently You Think That....... - RGA 16:13:44 01/13/06 (3)
- Re: Evidently You Think That....... - AudioHead 06:59:05 01/16/06 (2)
- Re: Evidently You Think That....... - RGA 18:14:06 01/16/06 (1)
- Funny You Should Mention ..... - AudioHead 06:33:12 01/17/06 (0)
- "getting soft." Victor and patrick were prepared to fill in for Ebert & Roper, but the network wouldn't go along with... - Audiophilander 15:29:11 01/06/06 (0)
- Re: Roger Ebert defends himslef against being accused as soft on movies... - DWPC 23:31:32 01/05/06 (12)
- Re: "...done absolutely nothing..."?? - rico 04:52:35 01/06/06 (11)
- His commentaries are inept. - Donald 18:33:18 01/06/06 (2)
- It is hard to learn when you already know everything.nt` - jamesgarvin 11:58:26 01/08/06 (0)
- Re: His commentaries are inept. - rico 10:35:35 01/07/06 (0)
- Plus.... - jamesgarvin 10:49:26 01/06/06 (7)
- "I am not sure what else he is supposed to do" - DWPC 12:11:22 01/06/06 (6)
- Re: "I am not sure what else he is supposed to do" - RGA 12:40:39 01/06/06 (5)
- Why relegate quality to art houses - DWPC 13:50:53 01/06/06 (4)
- Re: Why relegate quality to art houses - jamesgarvin 14:41:34 01/06/06 (3)
- He's not the top movie guru because of his written reviews - DWPC 16:14:17 01/06/06 (2)
- I understand your points... - RGA 13:23:25 01/07/06 (0)
- Re: He's not the top movie guru because of his written reviews - jamesgarvin 16:54:30 01/06/06 (0)
- Ebert's Background and Work -- other critics? - RGA 19:19:00 01/05/06 (1)
- While I do enjoy listening to... - mkuller 11:08:49 01/05/06 (10)
- Re: While I do enjoy listening to... - jamesgarvin 12:02:03 01/05/06 (9)
- I agree with you, and... - EBerlin 18:12:47 01/05/06 (0)
- Hahahah exactly.... - RGA 13:20:32 01/05/06 (7)
- A critic's job.... - mkuller 14:57:00 01/05/06 (6)
- Re: A critic's job.... - RGA 17:48:50 01/05/06 (0)
- Re: A critic's job.... - jamesgarvin 15:48:37 01/05/06 (4)
- On Film And Food Taste.... - AudioHead 12:41:22 01/10/06 (2)
- Re: On Film And Food Taste.... - jamesgarvin 13:29:34 01/10/06 (1)
- Re: On Film And Food Taste.... - AudioHead 10:35:58 01/11/06 (0)
- Re: A critic's job.... - RGA 18:01:43 01/05/06 (0)
- Is this much different than audio reviewers? - grantv 09:48:22 01/05/06 (3)
- Re: Is this much different than audio reviewers? - RGA 13:05:19 01/05/06 (2)
- Help me here... - mkuller 15:00:56 01/05/06 (1)
- Re: Help me here... - RGA 18:11:16 01/05/06 (0)
- Why should anyone care? - Victor Khomenko 06:22:17 01/05/06 (2)
- Re: Why should anyone care? - jamesgarvin 07:30:04 01/05/06 (1)
- Re: Why should anyone care? - RGA 12:48:21 01/05/06 (0)
- He's not getting soft, he's always been a philistine and a champion of mediocrity. - Donald 22:28:31 01/04/06 (8)
- You've probably done so before but please list your favorite critic(s). nt - tinear 09:04:32 01/05/06 (3)
- Jonathan Rosenbaum, Robin Wood, Tony Rayns, James Quandt, Donald Ritchie, Sarris, Acquarello. -nt- - Donald 20:50:45 01/05/06 (2)
- Re: Jonathan Rosenbaum, Robin Wood, Tony Rayns, James Quandt, Donald Ritchie, Sarris, Acquarello. -nt- - jamesgarvin 12:47:12 01/08/06 (1)
- Re: Jonathan Rosenbaum, Robin Wood, Tony Rayns, James Quandt, Donald Ritchie, Sarris, Acquarello. -nt- - RGA 15:56:19 01/08/06 (0)
- Re: He's not getting soft, he's always been a philistine and a champion of mediocrity. - RGA 23:07:28 01/04/06 (3)
- Leave the Philistines out of this! They were the creators of . . . - townsend 16:34:59 01/05/06 (0)
- Don't put words in my mouth. On the whole, he champions crap. - Donald 03:15:08 01/05/06 (1)
- Cliff Claven heard from again...nt - jamesgarvin 07:11:30 01/05/06 (0)