In Reply to: Re: Jonathan Rosenbaum, Robin Wood, Tony Rayns, James Quandt, Donald Ritchie, Sarris, Acquarello. -nt- posted by jamesgarvin on January 8, 2006 at 12:47:12:
My reviews of Ebert's 2005 -- well one's he raved about which either made his ten list or were runners up
I rate on letter grade B- is 3 stars(and recommended) A- is four stars - an A is on my top 100 all time list, An A+ is in my top 20here are films that I have seen that Ebert gave 4 stars to:
Batman Returns
RGA B+The Constant Gardener
RGA A-Crash
RGA A-Munich
RGA ASyriana
RGA BSideways
RGA BDr Strangelove (he reviewed it again)
RGA AThe Aviator
RGA BKill Bill Vol 2
RGA A-Kinsey
RGA BMillion Dollar Baby
RGA A-Monster
RGA B+Spider Man 2
RGA A-Seems ok to me - and it would seem most mainstream critics agree on these films for the most part.
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- Re: Jonathan Rosenbaum, Robin Wood, Tony Rayns, James Quandt, Donald Ritchie, Sarris, Acquarello. -nt- - RGA 15:56:19 01/08/06 (0)