In Reply to: A word on "Director's cut," in general: posted by tinear on November 18, 2007 at 06:32:42:
I find the extended versions of the Lord of the Rings movies and the director's cut of Ridley Scott's "Kingdom of Heaven" superior to the original versions. In each case the added material fleshes out characters and provides better continuity as far as I'm concerned.
I found the LOTR films annoying in the cinema releases, largely because of what was in the books but wasn't in the films. That probably hasn't improved all that much in the extended versions but they never seem to have annoyed me in the same way.
In 'Kingdom of Heaven", the additional material clarifies relationships between some of the characters, provides added information that makes at least one character more credible for me, and makes the political situation in Jerusalem much clearer which also helps for me.
In general you may certainly be right but in particular there are certainly some films which I enjoy considerably more in their director's cut editions.
In general you may be right
David Aiken
This post is made possible by the generous support of people like you and our sponsors:
Follow Ups
- …and in particular… - David Aiken 13:19:52 11/18/07 (33)
- he actually couldn't be more wrong - Analog Scott 05:07:07 11/19/07 (32)
- Not so fast... - tinear 12:06:15 11/19/07 (31)
- Um I said Aliens not Alien. - Analog Scott 17:57:03 11/19/07 (30)
- What a great example of a guy in denial. Read the quote, again. - tinear 08:45:50 11/20/07 (29)
- dude you aren't even making sense - Analog Scott 06:25:17 11/22/07 (2)
- RIDLEY Scott, analog. Jeesh. Do you understand context? nnt - tinear 15:30:25 11/23/07 (1)
- Yes. I said akiens was an example. James Cameron directed Aliens - Analog Scott 09:35:29 11/24/07 (0)
- RE: What a great example of a guy in denial. Read the quote, again. - jamesgarvin 12:35:36 11/20/07 (25)
- RE: Reeve's footage - rico 02:12:49 11/21/07 (0)
- Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - tinear 13:09:22 11/20/07 (23)
- man you really are clueless - Analog Scott 06:31:20 11/22/07 (0)
- RE: Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - jamesgarvin 14:19:39 11/20/07 (21)
- RE: Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - Peter H-son 22:05:58 11/21/07 (20)
- RE: Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - jamesgarvin 09:10:46 11/24/07 (12)
- RE: Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - Peter H-son 13:56:13 11/24/07 (10)
- RE: Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - Analog Scott 14:08:48 11/24/07 (9)
- RE: Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - Peter H-son 15:42:40 11/24/07 (8)
- RE: Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - Analog Scott 16:34:43 11/24/07 (7)
- RE: Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - Peter H-son 16:55:27 11/24/07 (6)
- God yet another idiot - Analog Scott 18:07:47 11/24/07 (5)
- RE: God yet another idiot - Peter H-son 18:50:07 11/24/07 (4)
- i have no problem with people disagreeing with me - Analog Scott 18:57:31 11/24/07 (3)
- RE: i have no problem with people disagreeing with me - Peter H-son 06:59:52 11/25/07 (2)
- RE: i have no problem with people disagreeing with me - Analog Scott 08:23:51 11/25/07 (1)
- RE: i have no problem with people disagreeing with me - Peter H-son 10:06:59 11/25/07 (0)
- RE: Perhaps it doesn't occur to you and the other guy that - Analog Scott 09:43:31 11/24/07 (0)
- I'm pretty sure Kubrick did - Analog Scott 06:38:26 11/22/07 (6)
- Blockbusters "suck" because of the general subject matter: no - tinear 15:36:59 11/23/07 (4)
- RE: Blockbusters "suck" because of the general subject matter: no - Analog Scott 09:55:01 11/24/07 (3)
- Directors' cuts of Larry of A or Godfather? They also had - tinear 14:35:38 11/24/07 (1)
- RE: Directors' cuts of Larry of A or Godfather? They also had - Analog Scott 16:37:11 11/24/07 (0)
- The guys sits on the beach, does not work, lives off his wife's dime, and you are only on "pulp?" Idiot.nt - jamesgarvin 10:22:30 11/24/07 (0)
- RE: I'm pretty sure Kubrick did - Peter H-son 07:15:22 11/22/07 (0)